Is Business Education at an Inflection Point?

Recent months have seen an outpouring ofcontributed to their ultimate downfall, but a culture of
comments on the state business education is in,greed and lack of transparency that all players so
spurred largely by spectacular failures of internationaleagerly subscribed to.
companies and the banking crisis. The presence ofPossibly, this feeling of being on top of the world,
large numbers of business school alumni hasremaining firmly in control and leading others, not
highlighted the role of Harvard, Wharton andmatter what values this leadership is based on in real
countless others in shaping a generation of leaderslife, fueled the descent into the latest financial crisis.
who have ushered their organizations into trouble.The ties to top business schools were again all too
Emanating from top learning institutions, like HBS,visible and the extent of damage done necessitated
widely accepted ideas have reached boardrooms anddeep reflection about how business education might
corridors of most majors firms around the world andactually contribute to failed notions that key
granted academic legitimacy to actions which endeddecision-makers live by while in office.
in what many describe as economic disaster. As aAll that sent shock waves down the collective spine
result of problems which are plain to see deans ofof the industry, but other forces have been exerting
tops schools and directors of consulting companiespressure on it as well. The most powerful of them is
have started talking about the whole teachinga push towards globalization of curricula, as student
industry being at the inflection point, facing itsgroups, case studies and real business become
toughest challenges to date and being confronted byincreasingly international. American corporate training
eventful choices. Is this serious tone justified?institutions wake up to it a bit late, but they do the
The impact of economic debacles that were partlycatching-up with matchless determination, as
engineered by business school graduates is hard notevidenced by the choice of the first Indian-American
to notice. Failed businesses, like Enron, were awashto run Harvard Business School and other
with ex-students of the most reputed learningglobally-minded innovations.
institutions in the world from the top echelonsAnother pressure is related to common criticism that
downwards. Their decisions and achievements hadcorporate training programs are too academic and
long been turned into teaching material in the form ofoften fall short of prepping people to real-world
revered case studies which praised their businesstasks. More and more institutions invest in finding
acumen to high heavens. It is safe to assume thatplacements in companies as part of academic
tight bonds between the then successfulexperience to ensure greater relevance and help
corporations and academic institutions went much,translate their theories into practical skills. It is no
much deeper than just intellectual influence intolonger enough to leave a business school with a head
financial support. Importantly, it is not just thefull of grand-sounding concepts.
wrong-headed university knowledge that might have