Is Venezuela's Chavez a Dictator?

My cousin has become an activist for the opposition,I'm sure Chavez is very aware of the fate of
a retired agronomist who will go into the barrios,Allende's peaceful revolution.
probably for the first time in her life, to work forHistory has consequences. Chavez has clearly taken
social change. If Chavez had done nothing else, hesteps to prevent either destabilization (arguably
has at least galvanized the middle class to think ofattempted by the labor federation CTV in 2002), or
those less fortunate, instead of hiding behind thea military coup, and his program to broaden
walls of their gated communities, even if they goVenezuela's market for oil beyond the US, and his
only to counter him politically. I expect that my cousinregional trade pacts are, in part, understandable
will learn at least as much as she will teach. Butdefensive measures, as well as a challenge to the
Chavez seems to be doing much more than that:Washington Consensus.
health care clinics, cooperatives, literacy programs,And why should he renew a TV license to a channel
water and electricity to the barrios, vacant landthat used it to support a coup against the legitimate
occupations and much more, including cutting thegovernment? Broadcast TV should recognize that it
poverty rate by 10%.has a public responsibility: it is granted a license to use
On the other hand, his political and security movesthe public's airwaves. If NBC supported a coup
are worrisome. He has six more years, and he hasattempt against President Bush, would its license be
consolidated all left-wing parties, and has begun aautomatically renewed?
campaign against the private media, denying theWhile he has made mistakes, and while his programs
renewal of a license for RCTV. The corporate mediahave only begun to scratch the surface of his
has been, admittedly, even more biased than Foxcountry's problems, Chavez offers something new,
News, stridently anti-Chavez, but democratsinspiring new leaders in Latin America to look for
everywhere get worried when freedom of the pressalternatives to the neo-liberal Washington Consensus
is threatened. He has also beefed up his military, anddominated by the US.
armed a peoples militia.We can just hope that the opposition will cohere
Given history, though, you can hardly blame Chavez.enough that Chavez will be kept honest and
The US did immediately support the coup d'etat thatdemocratic.
overthrew Chavez, the elected president, for twoNo leader, facing only token opposition, remains a
days in April, 2002, and there is conflicting evidencedemocrat for long--as witness our own government
as to whether the US had a part in the coup itself.under total Republican rule. Here's hoping that the
Further, it is incontestable that the US played a role inopposition in Venezuela will force at least the honesty
destabilizing Chile in the early 1970's and, at verythat we are hoping for from the Democrats taking
least, supported Pinochet's overthrow of the Socialistover Congress in this country.
government of Salvador Allende in September, 1973.